In the early 1990's a lovely little tale was told of a young girl that attend the school the next street over. Legend has it that a janitor from Gatewood Elementary murdered her, took her back to Carey's place and the various traits of the houses of Carey's place fueled the rumors. Stories say the porches were painted red to cover the blood stains, the Hatchett House might have been where he left her body, but was it on one of the driveways? Then, there are the stories about groaning playground swings that moved by themselves in the moonlight, children laughing in the darkness and cars acting a bit odd and sputtering their way over the street.
My favorite house in this little neighborhood is actually the Hatchett House with its interesting green shutters with hatchet cutouts. If you have a chance, drive through this short stretch of road and see how different it is from the rest of the neighborhoods in Oklahoma. The architecture alone is worth the trip.
As for the young girl that was murdered, no evidence of any such crime has been found on record. Since the neighborhood has only been around since the 1920's it would be easy to trace had it actually happened. But, the thrill of taking someone new down the rickety little street with its unique homes while recounting the tale of Scary Carey is still amusing.








